A relatively light-on-data article is up at Slashdot right now, and it casts aspersions both on the IBMers who contribute to Dojo and on the Foundation itself based on the Free Software party line that all software patents are inherently evil.
I won’t address the background point regarding software patents here. I’ll only to say that reasonable people can disagree on this, particularly when it comes to proposed solutions. What I would like to focus some attention on is the background that this patent filing is made against.
It’s clear to me that IBM filed this patent fully aware that they were giving away all follow-on rights to enforce it in anything but a defensive way for the benefit of the Foundation and users of Dojo. After watching IBM counsel decimate SCO in court, does anyone in the OSS world really think that IBM’s lawyers are fools? And if so, to what end?
It’s sad that Slashdot hasn’t, for a decade of coverage of IP issues, learned that licensing is harder than the zealots would have you believe and that malice isn’t always the intent of those who participate in communities with a commercial interest.
The good news here, of course, is that IBM is just as generous today toward the OSS and Dojo communities as they were yesterday. We have the legal documents to prove it.